History of the Challenge Coin

At a time when illiteracy was prevalent and skilled craftsmen did not carry resumes or written references, a system of challenges was created to verify the degree to which an individual had progressed within his trade. Using these challenges, an individual’s skill level could be verified without the need for written documentation. It was in this way that the early builders passed their craft from generation to generation, as construction techniques were preserved in order to build the wonders of the ancient world.

The use of challenge coins or membership tokens was adopted centuries ago during the early formation of secret societies based on the skilled trades systems of the early builders. These coins or medallions are carried by members of specific fraternal organizations in order to verify their affiliation with that group or to prove a certain level or degree of knowledge attained. In many secret societies, organizational history and tradition are closely guarded, so membership tokens and handshakes or grips were used to ensure that non-members were not allowed to infiltrate closed-door meetings or intellectual gatherings. Unknown members were required to pass a series of membership challenges including producing the membership token before being allowed to enter secret meeting areas.

The meaning behind the distribution of the Tailgating Hall of Fame® challenge coin has much less sinister undertones behind it. Our challenge coin is a membership identifier. It is carried by our members as they travel from city to city as an indicator of their affiliation with our organization. Members of the Tailgating Hall of Fame agree to provide an open environment for fellow masters of the art who seek similar company when on travel in enemy territory. As a network of tailgating diehards, it’s an opportunity to exchange trade secrets, introduce local traditions, and continue to foster the camaraderie of the blacktop culinarians that have spent years perfecting their craft. Visitors understand that they may have to provide a donation to participate in each member's tailgate, and they're happy to return the favor when another Hall of Famer is visiting from out of town.

The Tailgating Hall of Fame challenge coin is a two-sided, bronze enameled coin. The front side bears the Quest for 31® shield, while the Tailgating Hall of Fame crest appears on the back side of the coin. The crest features a shield with a football field depicted on its face. A chef’s hat adorns the top of the shield which is bisected diagonally by a grill spatula. A red Solo cup appears above the spatula with a flaming charcoal briquette below it. A scroll with an inscription that reads, "Tailgating Hall of Fame" rounds out the design.

The Military Roots of the Challenge Coin

While challenge coins may trace their lineage to the recognition tokens of ancient Rome, the modern tradition took shape during World War I, when a wealthy lieutenant arranged for bronze medallions to be minted for his squadron. One wartime tale recounts how a downed American pilot, stripped of all identification except his medallion held in a leather pouch, used this coin to prove his identity to wary French soldiers—likely saving his life.

This story gave rise to the custom of carrying one's coin at all times and checking others by slapping the coin on a bar or table, with the loser buying drinks for the group. The tradition matured during the World Wars and Korea, where Colonel William “Buffalo Bill” Quinn of the 17th Infantry commissioned one of the earliest documented military coins. These coins, often worn on chains, signified both unit pride and shared heritage.

Through the Vietnam era and beyond, coins became widespread across branches of the military. They recognized achievements, solidified unit identities, and helped authenticate comrades in foreign lands. In modern times, the act of a "coin check" remains a fun ritual, though it continues to reinforce belonging and esprit de corps.

Challenge Coins: Beyond the Battlefield

What began in ancient militaries has since expanded far beyond. Today, police, fire departments, government agencies, corporations, and even sports organizations use challenge coins to honor excellence, foster camaraderie, and mark special events. The tradition thrives as a playful yet meaningful badge of membership, with both ritual exchange and coin checks reinforcing shared identity.

The Tailgating Hall of Fame Challenge Coin

Drawing inspiration from both ancient traditions and modern adaptations, the Tailgating Hall of Fame challenge coin carries forward this legacy in the realm of tailgate culture. It serves as both® recognition and passport—affirming membership, encouraging generosity, and sparking conversation at tailgate events from coast to coast. Its lush bronze design reflects the artistry and fun of the blacktop, while every coin check strengthens the bonds of sportsmanship, culinary pride, and fellowship among Hall of Famers.

In short, our challenge coin is more than a token—it’s a tradition, a story, and a symbol of unity within the tailgating community—honoring the past while fueling the spirit of gameday gatherings for years to come.